The Best Crib Mattress Under $200

By Salma E.
July 8, 2022

Looking for the best crib mattress under $200? In this blog post, we’ll compare and review some of the top-rated mattresses in this price range.

The products mentioned on this page were independently selected by Babycious editors. As an Amazon Associate, Babycious may earn a commission from qualifying purchases

If you are a parent looking for the best crib mattress under $200, you have come to the right place.

In this blog post, we will compare and review some of the top-rated mattresses in this price range. We will also provide information on what to look for when shopping for a crib mattress and offer some tips on how to get the best deal.

So, whether you are just starting your search or you are already familiar with some of the options available, read on for helpful advice and insights!

Our Top Picks

Looking for a quick recommendation for the best crib mattress under $200? Here are our top picks:

Overall Best Crib Mattress under $200: Moonlight Slumber Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress
Best Crib Mattress for Small Budget (way under $200): Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress

Best Organic Crib Mattress under $200: Modera Organic Crib Mattress
Best Breathable Crib Mattress under $200: BABELIO Memory Foam Crib Mattress
Best Crib Mattress For Picky Sleepers under $200: Dourxi Crib Mattress

The Overall Best Crib Mattress under $200

Moonlight Slumber Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress

What we love

How picky can an infant be? It can be tough to find a crib mattress that checks all the boxes. You want something that is waterproof in case of accidents, lightweight for easy changing, and with two sleep surfaces for when your baby starts to roll over. This 5″ dual-sided mattress is perfect for newborns and toddlers. The infant side features high-density foam, while the other has plush material to offer comfort at every turn! Flip it upside down when your little one grows out of their beginner stage – just follow along with these handy arrows on the tag for guidance. All of the Moonlight crib mattresses are made with CertiPUR-US certified foam, which is wrapped in a woven fire barrier and protected by reinforced seams. This baby crib mattress is not only comfortable, but it’s hypoallergenic and waterproof. The durable stretch knit fabric will ensure that your little one has many restful nights on this bed! The exterior of the mattress is made of a quiet material with no “crunch”. The life expectancy of a crib mattress is 8 years. That’s why your Moonlight products come with an automatic lifetime policy, which covers all their mattresses.

Key specs:

Dimensions: 52 x 27.5 x 5 inches
Item Weight: ‎10 pounds
Mattress Type: Foam

Please note

You do need to use a mattress protector or you might end up with stains on the mattress.

The Best Crib Mattress for Small Budget (way under $200)

Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress

What we love

If you are on a tight budget, but still want to get a very good crib mattress for your baby, the Graco Premium Foam Mattress is the perfect balance between comfort for your baby while still providing excellent support. This mattress features GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR-US certification as well, meaning it was screened for over 10,000 chemicals and VOCs known to pollute indoor air. This crib mattress comes with a thin lining that covers the entire foam, and it also includes an extra-cozy zippered fabric cover with a waterproof inside.

Key specs:

Dimensions: 27.62 x 52 x 5 inches
Item Weight: ‎10.7 pounds

Mattress Type: Foam

Please note

Before using this mattress, be sure to let it fully expand for 48 hours, flip it over after the first 24 hours and make sure that the corners are expanded too.

This will ensure that no smell stays and that you can use the mattress in optimal conditions.

The Best Organic Crib Mattress under $200

Modera Organic Crib Mattress

What we love

The Modera Organic Crib Mattress is made with organic cotton and wool, making it safe for your little one. It’s also CertiPUR-US certified, so you know that this mattress will be free from harmful chemicals like lead, mercury, or formaldehyde. The dual firmness of this mattress makes it perfect for both babies and toddlers. The firm side features firm, high-density foam providing a safe surface for newborns to sleep on while the softer side has the firm support of the foam core, but has more cushion to accommodate bigger babies and toddlers with an additional layer of memory foam gel. We like that the sides are clearly labeled so you don’t have to guess which is which! And because it’s waterproof and washable, cleanup is easy! The exterior cover protects the mattress from diaper leaks, spilled milk, dust, dirt, and more. The protector is made of organic cotton, is gentle on baby’s skin, hypoallergenic, breathable, waterproof and washable, and perfectly safe for the environment. Just unzip the cover and toss it in the washing machine for stress-free cleaning.

Key specs:

Dimensions: 52 x 27.5 x 5 inches
Item Weight: ‎10 pounds
Mattress Type: Foam

Please note

The mattress instructions say it takes up to 72 hrs to fully expand. It may look ready though after just a few hours, but we recommend that you let it rest for the entire recommended period for optimal use.

The Best Breathable Crib Mattress under $200

BABELIO Memory Foam Crib Mattress

What we love

This crib mattress uses a high-quality mattress cover made of 44% Tencel and 56% polyester fiber, which is skin-friendly, breathable, and environmentally friendly. It has a double-sided sleep design. The firmer side is suitable for infants, and the softer side for toddlers. We love that it comes with a removable ultra-soft polyester bed cover and waterproof non-woven fabric lining. The zipper design makes the cover easy to remove and install. And the bed cover can be machine-washed or hand-washed directly. The mattress itself is made of CertiPUR-US certified high-quality foam with ventilation holes, which is safe, environmentally friendly, odorless and quality assured.

Key specs:

Dimensions: 52 x 27 x 5.5 inches
Item Weight: ‎11.08 pounds

Mattress Type: Foam

Please note

Some parents reported that this crib mattress looks more fluffy than it really is.

The Best Crib Mattress For Picky Sleepers under $200

Dourxi Crib Mattress

What we love

It’s a given that Dourxi makes high-quality mattresses, so we had to include one in our list! This crib mattress is designed to promote safety and comfort. The dual firmness – firmer, flat surface provides proper support for an infant while the softer memory foam side helps provide maximum relief in toddlers’ beds. We love the thoughtful design that ensures that your crib mattress grows with your baby all the way through toddlerhood. The mattress has three layers. High-density support core, open-cell memory foam, and Gel-infused memory foam which helps regulate the temperature inside and on the mattress for optimal comfort of sleeping for your baby. The mattress cover is removable and washer safe for easy cleaning and comes in a lovely bi-color design. This crib mattress is, of course, CertiPUR-US certified so the foam is free of harmful chemicals like phthalates, lead and mercury to name a few.

Key specs:

Dimensions: 51.97 x 27.56 x 4.72 inches

Item Weight: ‎9.58 pounds
Mattress Type: Foam

Our Verdict

There are a lot of different crib mattresses on the market these days, and it can be tough to figure out which one is the best for your needs. We’ve looked at the top-rated options under $200 to make the task easier for you.

The best crib mattress on our list is the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress. This mattress has everything you are looking for and more, it’s made from waterproof and hypoallergenic materials, is lightweight for easy changing, and features two sleep surfaces so your baby can always rest comfortably.

Still not sure ?

What to look for in a crib mattress

When shopping for a crib mattress, there are a few key factors to keep in mind. Many considerations may pop into your head as a parent, such as safety, comfort, and durability. This is the place where your little one will be spending hours slumbering after all! You’ll want it to be just perfect. Here are some important factors to keep in mind as you shop:

Size of the Mattress

Size really matters here. You will want to make sure that the mattress is the correct size for your crib. It should fit snugly and not be too big or too small. It’s important to ensure that no gaps are left between the crib and the mattress, as this can create a safety hazard. The sides of the crib should also be snug against the mattress to ensure that there isn’t any extra room for little hands or feet to get stuck between the mattress and crib.

Types of Mattresses

You will also need to consider the type of mattress you want for your baby. There are two main types: foam and innerspring. Foam mattresses are typically the cheapest and most lightweight option, but they may not be as durable as innerspring mattresses. Innerspring mattresses are more expensive but tend to be more durable than foam mattresses. They also offer better air circulation and are less likely to cause allergies.

Firmness of the Mattress

Next, you will want to think about the firmness of the mattress. This is an important consideration, as a too-firm mattress can be uncomfortable for your child and may even cause health problems. On the other hand, a too-soft mattress can be dangerous, as it may not provide enough support and could lead to SIDS. Most crib mattresses have a medium firmness, but you may want to experiment with a few different options before making a final decision.

Highlight: If you want to get the most out of your crib mattress though, we recommend getting a “dual-stage” mattress that has one firm side for the newborn and baby stage and the other side with more cushion for the toddler stage.

Safety and certifications

This is, of course, the most important consideration when choosing any product for your child. All crib mattresses sold in the United States must meet federal safety standards, but you may want to look for additional certification from organizations. Here are some of the certifications to look for:

GREENGUARD: This certification means that the mattress has been tested and found to meet stringent emissions standards for indoor air quality. This goes to say that the mattress has limited chemical off-gassing.

GREENGUARD Gold: Related to the Greenguard certification, this one has even more stringent emission limits for VOCs (Volatile Organic Compounds) that may have adverse health effects.

CertiPUR-US: This is another certification that means the mattress has been tested and found to meet rigorous standards for emissions, environmental stewardship, and durability.

Certifications can be important in helping you decide which crib mattress is right for your family. Having a label on your mattress usually means that the product is agreeable to your baby’s health and can be used without concerns.

Is organic content a priority?

If you are specifically looking for an organic crib mattress, there are a few certifications to look for. The most reputable certification is the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS), which is recognized by the USDA. This certification guarantees that the mattress has been made with at least 95% organic materials. If this is something you’re interested in, be sure to look for the GOTS certification when shopping for your crib mattress.

Highlight: Organic mattresses are made of natural materials and are generally more expensive, but they are also the most environmentally friendly.

How to get the best deal for a crib mattress?

Once you have considered all of the factors above, it is time to start shopping around for the best deal. The internet is a great resource for this, as you can compare prices and reviews from the comfort of your own home. However, it is always a good idea to head to your local baby store to test out the mattress in person. This way, you can be sure that it is the right fit for your crib and your budget.

Just keep in mind that there are a few different types of crib mattresses on the market. Some are made from foam, while others are made from coils. There is no right or wrong answer when it comes to choosing the perfect mattress for your baby. It simply depends on your personal preferences and needs.

The purpose of this article is informative and educational only. It’s not a substitute for medical consultation or medical care. We do not accept any responsibility for any liability, loss or risk, personal or otherwise, incurred as a consequence, directly or indirectly, from any information or advice contained here. Babycious may earn compensation from affiliate links in this content.

Salma E.

Salma is a mom of a two years-old and your host at babycious. Salma developed a passion for conscious parenting and lifestyle after entering motherhood and experiencing firsthand the joys of breastfeeding. She is an engineer by trade, which helps her bring a scientific and no-nonsense approach to every subject she tackles.